She Was Having Tea Alone—Until Duke’s Quadruplet Boys Whispered Pretend You’re Our Mother…

Chapter 5

They spoke like this for the better part of an hour — plain sentences traded back and forth like coin neither of them minded spending. In the day between their first meeting and this one, Mrs. Pruit had quietly confirmed what the square knew of Eleanor: where she lodged, the houses for which she mended, the debts she did not have, and the reputation she had earned for keeping her word. The Duke had asked for facts, not gossip, and Mrs. Pruit had given him nothing that made him distrust the judgment he had formed at the tea-room window.

At the end of the hour he asked, with no more weight than he had asked anything else, whether she would consider coming to the house some afternoons to sit with the boys while Mrs. Cross recovered her health.

He named a wage. She named it too high, and said so.

“It is what I pay anyone who is good at a hard thing,” he said.

“I have not proven I am good at it.”

“You proved it yesterday,” he said, “before you knew anyone was measuring.”

She did not know then that this was, to him, the whole of the matter. That he had spent four years watching people be kind to his sons in ways that curled at the edges once they learned whose sons they were. Governesses who softened their discipline once they understood the size of the fortune attached to it. Nursemaids who postured for his notice instead of the boys’ comfort.

She had done neither. She had not known there was anything to gain, and had been kind regardless, and he intended to build whatever came next on that foundation, and no other.

She said she would think on it. She did not say yes that morning because she did not trust things that arrived without a catch, and this had arrived with no catch she could find, which unsettled her more than if it had come with one.

She thought on it through a gray afternoon of mending, and through supper eaten alone, and she came to no conclusion except that four small boys had looked at her the day before as though she were the answer to a question they had been too polite to ask out loud, and that some things a person did not turn away from twice.

She did not know then that across the square, in a house two streets over, a duke sat by a cold hearth turning her name over in his mind like a coin he meant to spend carefully, and that Mrs. Pruit had already begun, quietly, the small work of finding out everything a woman like Eleanor Vance might need without knowing she needed it.

Eleanor came the next morning, and the one after that, and by the end of a fortnight the boys had stopped asking her to pretend at anything, because pretending had quietly become unnecessary.

She read to them by the nursery fire and mended the knees of their breeches, which no governess before her had thought to do herself rather than send out. And she learned to tell them apart by voice before she learned it by any other means. The eldest, quick and certain. The second, thoughtful. The third, quick to laugh. The fourth, whose name was Tom, quiet and watching, always watching, the way his father watched.

The Duke came to the nursery most evenings, ostensibly to bid the boys good night, and stayed longer than that errand required. He and Eleanor spoke of small things — the state of the roads, a book she had read twice, the particular stubbornness of the third boy, who would not eat carrots unless they were called something else entirely.

It was in these small conversations, traded over a fire in a room meant for children, that whatever had started in the tea room kept quietly building brick by unremarked brick, neither of them naming it, both of them aware of its shape.